Neither late afternoon thunderstorms nor dinner plans could stop the Natick community from packing the Johnson Elementary School gym on Wednesday for a listening session about what’s next for the 75-year-old building and surrounding property.
As was clear both at a recent Town Meeting session during which the Select Board officially took over responsibility for the Johnson property from the School Committee and at this public forum, the focus was to be on the future of the property, not rehashing the debate over whether the school should be shuttered in the first place. The decision to close the school was made in 2021, and last year the decision to close it at the end of this academic year was announced (instead of closing it next year under a more phased approach).
A celebration of Johnson, where glory days memories will flow, is slated for June 7.
While the intention of this meeting was not to relitigating past decision making, organizers made clear that attendees were welcome to both ask questions and share general comments and thoughts, acknowledging the emotions brought about by the school’s imminent closure. Bursts of applause broke out here and there following some comments.
Town Administrator Jamie Errickson emceed Wednesday night’s forum, and shared a general update on the situation before handing over the mic to attendees—a mix of parents, neighbors, town officials, and at least one student.
The strong message from the town, as it has been with other big decisions in recent years such as the fate of the South Natick Dam and former Eliot School, is that there will be plenty of opportunity for public engagement regarding Johnson’s future through an as-yet-to-be-designed process (you can sign up for updates). This assurance was met with a mix of appreciation and apprehension, with some concerned about whether such engagement translates into true influence over the eventual decisions of town officials.
Errickson, who described Johnson as “a beloved institution,” set expectations for the meeting early by stating “I can assure you that as of right now I have zero answers for you with regards to the long-term use of this property.” The process for making decisions will unfold in months and years to come, he said.
Don’t let us get Johnson-ed. Please support your local news source
In the short-term, immediate uses will be determined, including an allowance of a YMCA camp on the property this summer (one neighbor begged the town to look into better oversight of YMCA programs there given what he described as a wild after-school program). After-school recreation programs could most likely continue at the property, though the building’s ADA limitations would need to be taken into consideration. Errickson said the property would be analyzed by the town as part of a broader space analysis including other properties such as the Cole Center and East School.
Errickson did say that the town has budgeted to keep the playground and fields open to the public, and to maintain those facilities. Continued use of the property is one way to keep it safe, he said.
Numerous attendees were happy to hear that, though also sought assurances that the playground in particular would remain accessible to the community regardless of what develops on the property, which is zoned for single- and multi-family residential. Errickson said any zoning changes would require approvals on numerous fronts, including Town Meeting.
A public bidding process would be triggered if the town were to look into selling the property, Errickson said. If the town were to lease the property for less than three years, a less involved process is required under state law.

One theme in questions from attendees is how the interests of the immediate neighborhood would be prioritized. As a smallish community, some felt their interests were overrun by wider interests when it came to the closing of the school in the first place, and now they fear more of the same could happen.
“The Johnson community is… mighty but small. If there comes a point where the needs of this neighborhood come in conflict with the needs of the town, I just want the needs of this neighborhood to be taken seriously… these are our property values, this is our community, this is where we’ve laid down our roots,” said one attendee near the end of the meeting, which lasted just over an hour.
On this subject, Errickson returned to assurances that opportunities through multiple channels will exist for neighbors to be heard and have their concerns and desires taken seriously in the decision making process. Errickson said he hopes an engagement process will be mapped out by fall or winter that the Select Board can endorse. The timing of any decisions regarding long-term plans for the property remains to be seen based on what ideas come forth for its use.
Some asked about whether decision making could involve any sort of public vote, and Errickson said he has seen non-binding votes on issues in some communities.
There weren’t really a lot of ideas tossed out about what the property might be used for. Some referenced possible housing, another urged Natick to look at what other communities have done with such shuttered properties for inspirational ideas, such as an arts center. In a post meeting discussion, an attendee wondered if the property might serve for future early education needs for those ages 3-6.
One parent of five kids who had just wrapped up his last parent-teacher conference urged the town administration to take a cue from Johnson Jaguars values, symbolized by the paw prints students are given when they’re good to others. He went on to describe a mnemonic for PAW (purposeful, aspirational, wonder) that might guide the town in its decision making, and maybe even earn it a paw print.

